4.8
4.8/5
on Google and Facebook!

Affordable Car Insurance in Newmarket from $136/month

3 minutes can save you hundreds. Enter your postal code below and join thousands of Canadians saving on car insurance.

Secure. No Spam. No Fees.

Why You Can Trust MyChoice

MyChoice serves as an independent intermediary between you, financial institutions and licensed professionals without any additional charge to our users. In the interest of transparency, we disclose that we partner with some of the providers we write about – we also list many financial services without any financial gain. MyChoice does not operate a financial institution or brokerage and to ensure accuracy, our content is reviewed by licensed professionals. Our unique position means that we hold no recurring stake in your policy, ensuring our mission to help Canadians make better financial decisions is free of bias or discrimination. 

economical insurance-png

How to Compare Car Insurance Quotes with MyChoice

Comparing car insurance quotes with MyChoice is as simple as it gets:

Share Your Car Insurance Needs​

Tell us what you want out of your auto insurance.

Shop for the Best Deals​

Compare auto insurance quotes from the best Canadian insurers.

Secure Your Rates​

Pick the best deal and lock your rates on our site.​

Recent Quotes From Our Users

Monthly PremiumsDate & TimeQuote TypeAgeGenderCity
$105.53Jul 04, 2025, 10:03 AMAuto60FemaleNiagara Falls
$59.70Jul 04, 2025, 01:14 AMHome60FemaleHamilton
$29.98Jul 04, 2025, 09:09 AMTenant29FemaleNewmarket
$27.74Jul 04, 2025, 06:36 PMLife30MaleOakville
0

Canadians

have compared rates and saved money over the last 24 hours
Secure. No Spam. No Fees.
Updated on July 2, 2025

5 minute read

Quick Facts About Auto Insurance in Newmarket

  • Newmarket car insurance is MORE expensive than the Ontario average.
  • The average annual car insurance cost in Newmarket for a driver with comprehensive/collision coverage and a clean driving record is around $2,066.
  • Comparing Newmarket auto insurance quotes with MyChoice can save you up to $1,179 annually.

How Does Car Insurance Work in Newmarket?

Car insurance is mandatory in Ontario, but it’s important to understand the factors that influence your insurance premium and the types of coverage you should consider.

Below is a breakdown of what’s included in your car insurance package in Newmarket when you get a quote with MyChoice, categorized by mandatory and highly recommended coverages. Together, the mandatory and recommended coverage premiums reflect the average car insurance cost in Newmarket referenced above.

Coverage TypeWhat’s IncludedAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Mandatory– Third-Party Liability
– Accident Benefits
– Uninsured Automobile
$922
Highly
Recommended
– Direct Compensation:
Property Damage
– Collision
– Comprehensive
– OPCF 20
– OPCF 27
– OPCF 44R
– OPCF 39
– OPCF 43
$1,145
Coverage Total:$2,066

Mandatory Coverages

Coverage TypeCoverage DetailsAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Third-Party LiabilityProtects you if you injure someone
or damage property while driving,
and covers legal costs if you’re sued
$289
Accident BenefitsCovers medical costs, income
replacement, and more for you and
others injured in an accident,
regardless of fault
$617
Uninsured AutomobileProtects you if you’re hit by an
uninsured or an unidentified driver
and suffer injuries or vehicle damage
$16
Coverage Total:$922

*The above coverages are mandatory in Newmarket and will always be included in a standard car insurance quote.

Highly Recommended Coverages

Coverage TypeCoverage DetailsAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Direct Compensation:
Property Damage
Covers damage to your own vehicle
if you’re not at fault in an accident
with another insured driver in Ontario.
$507
CollisionCovers your vehicle if you hit another
car or object and you’re found at fault.
$309
ComprehensiveCovers damage to your vehicle from
non-collision events like theft, vandalism,
fire, or weather.
$223
OPCF 20:
Loss of Use
Pays for rental or other transportation
if your car is out of service after an
at-fault accident or comprehensive claim.
$26
OPCF 27:
Rental Vehicle
Extends your coverage to rented or
borrowed vehicles, protecting you if
damage occurs while you drive them.
$27
OPCF 44R:
Family Protection
Covers you and your family if you’re
hit by an uninsured, underinsured, or
hit-and-run driver and their coverage
isn’t enough.
$21
OPCF 39:
Accident Forgiveness
Prevents your insurance premiums from
increasing after your first at-fault
accident, as long as you stay with
the same insurer.
$30
OPCF 43:
Waiver of Depreciacion
Ensures you get the full purchase price
back—not a depreciated value—if your
new vehicle is written off.
$2
Coverage Total:$1,145

*Any of the above highly recommended coverages in Newmarket may be removed from your quote, but we strongly recommend keeping them to have adequate protection.

How Newmarket Car Insurance Rates Compare to Nearby Cities

Newmarket’s car insurance rates are some of the highest in the region. You can see how they compare to some of the neighbouring cities in the table below.

CityAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Newmarket, ON$2,066
Aurora, ON$2,023
Richmond Hill, ON$2,309
Markham, ON$1,686
Vaughan, ON$2,451
Bradford, ON$1,871

Car Insurance Cost in Newmarket by Age

Age is a major driving factor in whether you can expect higher insurance premiums. Generally, the idea is that older drivers have more experience and are thus more likely to be responsible and capable of avoiding accidents. 

Drivers under the age of 25 can expect higher insurance premiums, while those in their 50s and 60s can expect the lowest insurance rates. However, once you reach a certain age, your premium rates start to rise again – usually when you reach the age of 65 or become a senior citizen

Based on studies, 75-year-old male drivers pay 21% more for auto insurance than 55-year-old male drivers. This is because as people get older, they go through physical changes that can affect their driving ability, such as changes in vision, attention, fitness, and reaction time. 

Take a look at how much car insurance costs can vary by age in Newmarket:

AgeAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Average Savings with MyChoice
18-20$5,929$1,179
21-24$3,058$608
25-34$2,355$468
35-44$2,066$411
45-54$1,756$349
55-64$1,632$325
65+$1,673$333

Car Insurance Cost in Newmarket by Driving History

Take a look below at how car insurance quotes vary by violation in Newmarket:

Driving ViolationAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Clean driving record$2,066
Insurance cancellation
due to non-payment
$2,872
Licence suspension for
alcohol-related offences
$2,169
One at-fault accident$4,049
Minor speeding ticket$2,500

All estimated rates are based on a 35-year-old female driving a 2018 Honda Civic four-door.

Your driving record plays a major role in determining the cost of your insurance premiums. Insurance companies will usually request the following:

  • Demerit point total
  • Any convictions, suspensions, and reinstatements under the Highway Traffic Act and Criminal Code of Canada
  • Records of collisions
  • Any driver’s license replacements/renewals

A clean driving record will help you get lower premiums, while a record laden with violations will get you tagged as a high-risk driver and cause insurance companies to charge you more.

In Ontario, driving violations remain on your record for two years, but they can affect your premium rates for far longer. 

Car Insurance Cost in Newmarket by Vehicle Model

Below is a breakdown of the estimated insurance costs for various car models in Newmarket. This should give you an idea of what you can expect to pay for car insurance based on the vehicle model you drive.

Car ModelAverage Annual
Car Insurance Premium
Honda$1,896
Toyota$2,175
Tesla$2,029
Hyundai$2,084
Audi$2,568
BMW$2,405
Mazda$1,926
Mercedes$2,047
Subaru$1,793
Volkswagen$1,901

The Best Car Insurance Brokerages in Newmarket

Car insurance brokers help you choose the right auto insurance policy by answering your questions and comparing policy offers.

Here are several brokers in Newmarket that you can contact for extra assistance when seeking car insurance:

BrokerageAddressPhone number
Zoobla Financial17665 Leslie St Unit # 27,
Newmarket, ON L3Y 3E3, Canada
+19058364185
BrokerLink247 Main St S,
Newmarket, ON L3Y 3Z4, Canada
+19058367283
George Rappos Desjardins
Insurance Agent
1271 Gorham St Unit 12,
Newmarket, ON L3Y 8Y7, Canada
+19058957775
Billyard Insurance Group
– Newmarket
390 Davis Dr #102,
Newmarket, ON L3Y 2N9, Canada
+18882280202

Driving in Newmarket

Planning to move to or visit Newmarket? It helps to know more about driving in the area. Here are some key facts about driving in Newmarket you should know:

  • Major highways in Newmarket: 404
  • Public transit options: York Region Transit (bus), GO Trains
  • Ridesharing services: Uber, Blacklane, Lyft, Talixo, SuperShuttle
  • Parking space providers: The Town of Newmarket, private lots
  • Top tourist attractions: Fairy Lake Park, Upper Canada Mall, Newmarket Riverwalk Commons, Holland Marsh Wineries
  • Busy intersections: Yonge and Mulock, Prospect Street and Mulock, Yonge and London Road
  • Airports: N/A

Main Mode of Commuting in Newmarket

If you live in Newmarket, it helps to know more about commuting there to ensure you get to work on time. Here’s a detailed look at the commuter data in Newmarket:

  • Average commute distance: The average Newmarket resident travels x km to their workplace or school. 
  • Commute duration: While Newmarket is a small town, commute times are often somewhat long. Only 54.3% of households in Newmarket take under 30 minutes to get to work, while 22.4% of them spend 30 to 44 minutes on their commute.
  • Main mode of commuting: Personal vehicles are the most popular mode of commuting in Newmarket, with a 90% share of households. Public transit and walking take second and third with 3.9% and 3.8% shares, respectively.

Driving Conditions in Newmarket

Various weather and driving conditions like snow and rain can affect your auto insurance premiums. Here’s an overview of driving conditions in Newmarket: 

  • Average annual rainfall: 81 mm
  • Average annual snowfall: 96 mm
  • Rainy days per year: 110
  • Rainiest month in Newmarket: June
  • Driest months in Newmarket: January
  • Snow days per year: 110
  • Snowfall months in Newmarket: October-April

Traffic in Newmarket

While Newmarket qualifies as a town, it’s one of the bigger towns in the area due to being the regional seat of York. It’s also a relatively dense town compared to other similarly-sized places.

Here’s a quick look at the key traffic statistics in Newmarket:

  • Population: 87,942 people live within Newmarket’s city limits.
  • City area: Newmarket’s city area spans 38.50 km2.
  • Busiest highways: Newmarket is connected to Toronto through Highway 404. It’s also connected to Highway 400 by way of Highway 9.

Newmarket Car Insurance FAQs

Is ridesharing insurance available in Newmarket?

Ridesharing insurance for Uber and Lyft drivers is available in Newmarket. Ask your insurer for more details.

How much does Newmarket car insurance cost?

Newmarket car insurance costs $2,066/year.

Why should you compare car insurance rates in Newmarket?

You should compare car insurance rates in Newmarket because different insurers provide different coverage at different prices. Comparing rates help you choose which policy has the best value.

What information do you need for an auto insurance quote in Newmarket?

You need to provide basic personal details and vehicle information like production year, make, and model to get a basic auto insurance quote. You can get more accurate quotes by disclosing extra information, like your driving record and past traffic violations.

How you can get cheaper car insurance in Newmarket?

Compare car insurance rates in Newmarket with MyChoice, or visit our main car insurance page to learn other ways of getting cheap car insurance quotes.

Methodology

Sample Size

We analyzed over 50,000 auto insurance quotes across Canada.

Profiles

Average rates were calculated using a standard profile and incident profiles. All personal details pertaining to the quotes and policies have been kept confidential.

Standard Profile

Single driver, one car, currently insured, and a pristine driving record. Our base profile is a 35-year-old individual (both male and female) with a spotless driving record.

Incident Profiles

We examined how rates change by evaluating profiles with a clean record (standard), one at-fault accident, a single speeding ticket, license suspension for alcohol related offenses and insurance cancellation due to non-payment.

Vehicle Details

These individuals own a 2018 Honda Civic, commute five days a week, and cover a distance of 15,000 kilometres annually.

Vehicle Models

Costs were also analyzed for different vehicles: Mazda CX-5, Ford Escape, Toyota Corolla, Honda Accord, Chevrolet Equinox, and the base 2018 Honda Civic.

Age and Homeownership

Profiles from age 18-65 (standard: 35 years) were considered. Depending on age, individuals might rent or own their homes. Age-related regulations may vary across provinces.

Team

MyChoice data science, MyChoice research.

Sources

1. Mychoice.ca Internal Data, How Car Insurance Works, Ontario, Newmarket, Car Insurance Quotes Collected, 2025.

2. Mychoice.ca Internal Data, Car Insurance Rates in Nearby Cities, Ontario, Newmarket, Car Insurance Quotes Collected, 2025.

3. Mychoice.ca Internal Data, Rate Cost By Age, Ontario, Newmarket, Car Insurance Quotes Collected, 2025.

4. Mychoice.ca Internal Data, Rate Cost By Driving History, Ontario, Newmarket, Car Insurance Quotes Collected, 2025.

5. Mychoice.ca Internal Data, Rate Cost By Vehicle Model, Ontario, Newmarket, Car Insurance Quotes Collected, 2025.

6. City of Newmarket Website, Driving & Transit Information. Data Collected in 2025.

7. Statistics Canada, 2021, Census of Population, Ontario, Newmarket, Main Mode of Commuting. Data Collected in 2025.

8. Weather Network Canada, Historical Averages, Ontario, Newmarket. Data Collected in 2025.

9. 511 Ontario Traveller Information, Ontario, Newmarket. Data Collected in 2025.

Congratulations! You made it to the end!

Now, here is the easy part: complete your quote in under 2 minutes
Secure. No Spam. No Fees.

Discover More About

June 30, 2025
If you’re looking to import a car into Canada, be prepared to face unique insurance challenges. Learn what insuring an imported car entails.
June 23, 2025
PLPD insurance is the minimum amount of coverage you need to be able to drive in Ontario legally. Learn exactly what PLDP insurance covers.
June 13, 2025
Is your car sharing your data without your consent? Find out how automakers collect your personal information and best practices to protect your privacy.

Even More Ways To Save on Insurance