The Cheapest Cars to Insure in Ontario (2024 Update)

3 minutes can save you hundreds. Give us a call at the number below to talk to a licensed expert and join thousands of Canadians saving on car insurance.

3 minutes can save you hundreds. Enter your postal code below and join thousands of Canadians saving on insurance.

Secure. No Spam. No Fees.

Why You Can Trust MyChoice

MyChoice serves as an independent intermediary between you, financial institutions and licensed professionals without any additional charge to our users. In the interest of transparency, we disclose that we partner with some of the providers we write about – we also list many financial services without any financial gain. MyChoice does not operate a financial institution or brokerage and to ensure accuracy, our content is reviewed by licensed professionals. Our unique position means that we hold no recurring stake in your policy, ensuring our mission to help Canadians make better financial decisions is free of bias or discrimination. 

Article Contents
By <span>Aren Mirzaian</span>
By Aren Mirzaian

Updated on February 22, 2024

Visit author page
By <span>Aren Mirzaian</span>
By Aren Mirzaian

Updated February 22, 2024

Visit author page

9 minute read

Article Contents

A List of the Cheapest Vehicles to Insure in Ontario in 2024

Different cars come with different premiums, so when it comes to buying a car in Ontario, finding the cheapest cars to insure can become rather tedious. Luckily, there are plenty of excellent cars available with very reasonable average insurance quotes, that’s why we’ve put together the following list of the 14 cheapest cars to insure in Ontario in 2024.

cheapest cars to insure in ontario

Certain Factors Will Determine How Cheap Your Car is to Insure

There are lots of different elements that go into calculating your insurance premium, some are related to the driver and some are related to the vehicle. Some examples include:

Vehicle Type

This factor also plays a big role in your insurance rates considerably. Depending on the make and model of your car, you can save or spend more than the average. This price range can differ by more than $500. Some types of vehicles such as hybrid vehicles may also enjoy a discount from some insurers. Installing an anti-theft feature or to your car may also help you save on your insurance premiums.

Car Age

The age of your vehicle is also a concern for your insurance rate. A person driving the same vehicle for five years may enjoy a lower rate than someone having driven the same car for less than a month. However, an old car’s insurance can also be heavier than a new car, especially if that car is a restored classic or expensive and tedious to repair. Ultimately, driving a car that is safe, affordable and inexpensive to repair can save you money on insurance in the long run.

Purpose & Frequency 

Driving for leisure versus driving for business or commercial purposes also impacts your insurance rates. The former may cost you less than if you use your car for work. Further, long hours of daily commute will face a higher insurance rate than an occasional or a weekend driver.

That being said, let’s get into some of the cheapest vehicles to insure in Ontario for 2024.

Mitsubish Mirage

The Mitsubishi Mirage ticks all the boxes if you are after a small and compact, fuel-efficient, trendy hatchback that can operate like a breeze in any notorious Canadian weather situations. The Mirage boasts an extremely economical gas usage but doesn’t sacrifice power and performance, making it more capable in any conditions. With numerous features and technology coming standard on the vehicle to make your drive all the little easier, you will soon fall in love with the Mirage and it won’t break back when it comes to your insurance.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $6,537.53/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.33

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,267.96

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,445/year

Chevrolet Spark

The Chevrolet Spark is a nifty little hatchback not only looks the part but won’t break the bank when it comes to insurance. The Spark is often regarded as one of the most reliable hatchbacks within its class, boasting a great safety rating and manufactured from a reliable brand like Chevrolet certainly helps. This little car is perfect for buzzing around the city and getting you from A to B, it doesn’t ooze luxury but you count on it to get you where you need to go.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $6,787.67/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.34

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,341.60

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,457/year

Toyota Corolla

The Toyota Corolla is known for its reliability and has a practical, everyday appeal; Toyota sells over one million Corollas every year, if you’re looking for proof of this car’s worth, there it is. The Corolla’s standard safety features are some of the best in its class, in fact features that are found standard on the Corolla are typically optional add-ons for other cars. One of the best things about the Corolla is peace of mind, it’s a car you really don’t have to worry about too much after you buy it. It may not be the fastest or most luxurious, but it’s incredibly reliable and it’s an excellent commuter car so unless you’re looking for something a little more fancy, you won’t regret purchasing a Corolla.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $6,960.57/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.35

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,722.40

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,459/year

Mazda 3

 

If you thought its impossible to find a sporty looking car that also has low cost insurance, think again. Mazda’s have always been known for being affordable and high-quality, the Mazda3 is no different. Being a small car it is know for having excellent handling, incredible fuel economy, and a smart interior design. So whether you’re on the highway or in the city, this Mazda will make you feel right at home. It’s a zippy little car that will do everything you need making it rather fun to drive, so just because your budget can’t afford a sports car doesn’t mean you can’t find a car that will feel like one.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,096.40/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.35

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,694.30

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,476/year

Honda Civic

The Honda Civic is a tough one to beat. The Civic is constantly one of the best 4-door compacts on the market, it’s civilized, looks sleek with a ride that’s smooth and crisp. It genuinely gives a feeling of luxury which is surprising considering how cheap it is to buy and insure. They’re known for being very reliable and it’s fuel economy is top-class. And on top of that, it’s one of the cheapest cars to insure in Ontario. The Honda Civic is a great small car that’s been a consistent performer for a number of years.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,645.69/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.38

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,694.30

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,481/year

Hyundai Elantra

The Elantra is a top-of-the-line compact car, it’s stylish, fuel efficient, reliable, and safe. This car should absolutely be on your list of considerations of cheap cars to insure with decent engine power and a smooth ride. Usually cars in this class don’t have a lot of high-tech, but with the Elantra there is a wide variety of technology available and in fact, it has a very similar price point when compared to the more expensive Sonata.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,578.34/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.38

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,698.98

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,503/year

Chevrolet Cruze

The Chevrolet Cruze is a comfortable 4-door sedan with plenty of room on the inside and when it comes to standard features, the Cruze definitely has its fair share. The Cruze comes with an “Infotainment System” which is basically a touch-screen setup that will sync with your phone. It’s fuel economy is excellent making it an ideal car for all types of trips and perhaps the most appealing aspect of the Cruze for some people could be the price. The Cruze has one of the lowest starting prices in its class making it an excellent choice for budget buyers and its also one of the cheaper cars for insurance in Ontario.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,723.50/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.36

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,647.46

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,524/year

Toyota Camry

The Toyota Camry is easily considered one of the best mid-size cars on the market today, it seats the standard five people and has plenty of extra room within the interior. In addition, it also has a good sized trunk so you will have plenty of room for everyday errands and Toyota has a long history of being reliable. Finally, the Camry has consistently been awarded very high safety scores which can often be a deal breaker, when it comes to a family car. In regards to cost, the Camry is is a little bit more expensive to run and insure compared to other vehicles on this list but the other aspects mentioned certainly make that up.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,870.63/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.39

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,947.21

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,549/year

Volkswagen Golf

The Volkswagen Golf is a practical, German made hatchback. This reliable compact car is large enough for a family and kids but doesn’t break the bank when it comes to fuel consumption. One of the most interesting aspects of the Golf is the very diverse line-up on offer. For the sake of this analysis we looked at the costs on the standard model, but there are plenty of other models out there, such as the sporty wagon also available. Overall, the Volkswagen Golf is a reliable car with an affordable estimated annual driving cost that may just justify the additional price.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,735.50/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.39

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,830.12

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,563/year

Kia Forte

With the Forte, Kia delivers exactly what you would expect from a compact car. It’s cheap, fuel efficient, has a roomy interior and in its class, it’s one of the cheaper cars you can find. The interior feels high-quality and has plenty of nice tech features. However, when it comes to safety, the Forte lacks some of the standard safety options some of its competitors have so you may have to look at having additional extras here. Even though adding the optional features will bring up the price, it could still be worth it depending on what you’re looking for. Despite these minor setbacks, the Forte is still a good value family vehicle worth considering.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $7,976.09/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.40

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $2,022.15

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,571/year

Nissan Sentra

The Sentra is, by definition, a compact car, but has some midsize qualities on offer with a roomy interior space and a good sized trunk. This vehicle has a high rating for fuel economy and great safety ratings, making it one of the best performers within its class. It’s engine, however, tends to be a little less powerful which may deter some people but it isn’t necessarily a bad thing if your predominantly driving in a city environment. Of course, this doesn’t mean it’s a bad car, it’s very reliable, has top-notch safety scores and very high fuel economy. It’s overall an excellent everyday car but might be a little on the pricey side for insurance when compared to similar cars from its class on this list.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $8,532.68/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.43

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,980.00

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,575/year

Volkswagen Jetta

This is the second Volkswagen on the list, but unlike the Golf, the Jetta is a bit more expensive to insure coming in at the final position on our list. That being said it’s a 4-door compact car with good power for its size, as for the interior that is said to be rather bland and boring, but despite this, it is very spacious. While the Jetta may be more expensive overall, its features, safety, and reliability will make it the perfect fit for more than a few car owners.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $9,323.03/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.47

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $2,002.24

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,580/year

Dodge Caravan

The Dodge Caravan relies on its space, comfort and convenience to define your driving experience. The 2020 Grand Caravan offers up to 81 comfortable seating configurations to choose from with the iconic Stow ‘n Go Seating to easily change to cargo mode. It also offers outstanding storage versatility in its Super Console. There are several levels of available multimedia centres and each one offers essential features to keep you entertained. Their UConnect system is designed to give you the safety, security, information and entertainment when you travel which also features hands‑free operation for safety. The 2020 Grand Caravan was designed from the wheels up to offer advanced safety technologies which gives you insight on your blind spots.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $3,345.29/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.20

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $2,604.60

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,591/year

Kia Sorrento

The Kia Sorento makes travel easy while giving you the time and space to be inspired. It features heated steering wheel and front seats, rear cross traffic alert with lane keeping assist. With all-wheel drive, you will have all the traction and control to carve through the elements with ease. Move confidently with the Advanced Forward Collision Avoidance Assist with Junction Turning Function. This state-of-the-art safety feature warns you with an audible alert if it detects a vehicle approaching yours at a junction. The Blind Spot Collision Avoidance Assist actively monitors your blind spots for approaching vehicles. If it sees that a collision is possible, it can intervene to reduce the risk or impact.

Estimated Total Annual Driving Costs: $2,456/year

Total Cost per Kilometre: $0.18

Fuel Cost per Year (Gas): $1,950

Estimated Average Insurance Cost: $1,604/year

The Cheapest SUVs to Insure

SUVs are one of the most popular types of vehicles to own with a wide range to choose from. Here is our breakdown of some of the cheapest SUVs to insure.

SUV Vehicle ModelEst. Insurance Rate P/Y
Hyundai Kona$2,543
Toyota Highlander$2,578
Toyota RAV4$2,612
Ford Escape$2,642
Subaru CrossTrek$2,681
Volkswagen Tiguan$2,715
Nissan Rogue$2,739
Honda CR-V$2,755
Jeep Wrangler$2,763
Hyundai Tucson$2,791

The Cheapest Small Cars to Insure

Small cars are still as popular as ever, ideal for an urban lifestyle and often one of the more cheaper vehicle types to run. Here is our list of some of the cheapest small cars to insure and while you’re here check out our list of the top 10 small cars in Canada for 2024.

Small Vehicle ModelEst. Insurance Rate P/Y
Mitsubishi Mirage$1,445
Chevrolet Spark$1,457
Toyota Corolla$1,459
Mazda 3$1,476
Honda Civic$1,481
Hyundai Elantra$1,503
Chevrolet Cruze$1,524
Toyota Camry$1,549
Volkswagen Golf$1,563
Kia Forte$1,571

The Cheapest Electric Vehicles to Insure

Electric Vehicles are consistently growing in popularity and they are a vehicle model you should certainly consider when looking to purchase your next car. Here is our list of some of the cheapest electric vehicles to insure.

Electric Vehicle ModelEst. Insurance Rate P/Y
Ford Focus EV$1,807
Volkswagen E Golf$2,225
Tesla Model 3$2,329
Kia Soul$2,739
Nissan Leaf$2,861

The Cheapest Trucks to Insure

Trucks are a common vehicle option when choosing your next car, they offer a range of versatility especially in all weather types. Here is our list of some of the cheapest trucks to insure.

Truck Vehicle ModelEst. Insurance Rate P/Y
GMC Canyon$1,789
Chevrolet Silverado$1,812
Ford F-150$1,830
Toyota Tacoma$1,876
Nissan Titan$1,923
Dodge Ram 1500$2,053
Hyundai Santa Cruz $2,104

Methodology

We analyzed a range of the best automotive sites across the web to help curate these lists of cheapest vehicles to insure, as well as supplementing from our own internal data gathered from July 2022 to July 2023.

We used the following criteria to help find the estimated average insurance rate: clean driving record, based in the Greater Toronto Area (cheapest postal code), male, aged 35 and using vehicle for personal use. Note, insurance estimates can vary based on your specific driving situation. 

Congratulations! You made it to the end!

Now, here is the easy part: complete your quote in under 2 minutes

Discover More About

The Alberta government has announced a comprehensive reform of the auto insurance system, set to take effect in 2024. Read on to learn more.
Learn about ten essential car maintenance tips that every vehicle owner should know, whether auto insurance covers car maintenance and more.
Learn about intricacies of taxes on used vehicles in Ontario, and get insights and tips ob how to navigate this aspect of car ownership.

Even More Ways To Save