After a minor car accident, many drivers wonder if it makes more sense to pay for repairs out of pocket instead of filing an insurance claim. It’s not always an easy decision. Before deciding how to proceed, consider repair costs, who’s at fault and whether you may see an increase in premiums if you make a claim.
Filing a claim makes sense in some situations; paying out of pocket may make sense in others. Consider the factors below before deciding.
To prepare this article, our team looked into FSRA’s guidance, Ontario’s collision-reporting instructions and the standard Ontario Automobile Policy.
Filing a Claim vs. Paying Out of Pocket at a Glance
- Paying out of pocket has an upfront cost, but an at-fault claim may affect your premiums. Consider which option makes the most sense for your current financial situation.
- Claims can affect no-claims discounts and future insurance rates. Accidents and repairs may also appear on a vehicle-history report and affect resale value.
- If the expected insurance payment is close to your deductible, paying for the repair yourself may make more sense.
Deciding whether to file a claim or cover the cost yourself can feel like a bit of a gamble. While auto insurance is there to help with unexpected expenses, filing a claim may not always be the more financially sound choice. Let’s take a closer look at the factors you should consider before coming to a decision.
Reporting the accident to your insurer and asking the insurer to pay for your damage are not necessarily the same decision. You may still have to report the accident even if you plan to pay for your own repairs.
Pros and Cons of Filing a Car Insurance Claim
Claiming through your insurance can be a financial lifesaver when dealing with hefty repair bills after a covered accident. However, an at-fault claim may lead to higher premiums down the road. There’s also a chance of the claim being denied if the damage isn’t covered by the policy.
Here’s a straightforward breakdown to help you weigh your choices:
Pros
- Financial relief: You can use your auto insurance coverage to handle large repair, replacement and liability costs, giving you peace of mind when unexpected expenses pop up.
- Access to support services: Auto insurers often connect policyholders with towing, rental cars and claims support, making it easier to handle repairs and paperwork.
- Liability protection: If you’re in an accident involving injuries or other vehicles, notifying your insurer allows it to investigate and respond under the liability coverage in your policy.
Cons
- Possible premium increase: An at-fault claim may increase your premium at renewal. Multiple claims in a short period could also affect your rates or how an insurer assesses your application.
- Loss of a no-claims discount: Many Canadian insurers offer discounts for staying claims-free. Depending on the insurer and type of claim, filing one could affect that discount.
- Deductible expense: Even if the damage is covered, you may still have to pay a deductible. If it’s on the higher side, filing a small claim might not be worth it.
Pros and Cons of Paying Out of Pocket
Pros
- Possible premium protection: Paying for your own repairs may help you avoid a claim for damage to your vehicle, but it doesn’t guarantee that your premium or discount will be protected.
- Control over repairs: You can choose the repair shop and compare prices without going through the insurer’s claims process.
Cons
- High upfront cost: Paying out of pocket can hit your wallet hard, especially if the damage ends up costing more than you expected. After receiving an estimate, you may find that your savings aren’t enough to cover a large repair bill.
- Potential for hidden damage: What looks like a small fix at first could turn into a bigger problem and cost more than your insurance deductible.
- Another claim could follow: If another person was involved, they may later make an injury or property-damage claim even if you paid for your own repairs.
The Hidden Financial Ripples of a Claim
Filing a claim might seem like the easiest solution at the time, but it can affect your finances in other ways.
When Paying Out of Pocket May Make Sense
Auto insurance exists to cover unexpected losses, but it’s not always obvious when it’s smarter to pay for repairs yourself. Understanding your options can help you make an informed decision.
Minor Fender Benders
The repair cost may be lower than or close to your deductible. For instance, if your deductible is $1,000 and the repair estimate is $1,200, the potential insurance payment may be only $200.
Before deciding, check for hidden damage and make sure you still meet any reporting requirements.
Accidents With Minimal Damage
If no one was injured and no other property was damaged, you may consider paying for minor cosmetic damage to your own car.
Get a written estimate first. If the vehicle is leased or financed, check whether the agreement requires the damage to be reported or repaired.
A Long Claims-Free History
If you’ve built up years of claims-free discounts, a small repair bill might cost less than losing the discount.
Don’t make the decision based only on the discount, though. Consider the repair cost, your deductible, who was at fault and whether someone else could make a claim.
When Should You File a Claim?
While paying out of pocket may work for minor damage to your own car, the situation changes when injuries, other people or major damage are involved.
Serious Injuries or Major Damage
Injuries and major vehicle damage can result in costs far beyond a reasonable out-of-pocket amount. Report the accident to your insurer and follow any police or collision-reporting requirements.
Accidents Involving Other People
Your policy’s liability coverage may protect you if someone else makes a claim for injuries or property damage. Don’t try to settle a serious third-party claim without notifying your insurer.
Lease or Loan Requirements
If your vehicle is leased or financed, the agreement may require certain coverage and may place conditions on how damage is reported or repaired.
Damage That May Not Be Obvious
Damage may be worse than it first appears. Filing a claim may help cover additional repairs discovered after the vehicle is inspected, subject to the policy and deductible.
Bottom Line
- Balance short-term savings against possible long-term costs. Sometimes, paying a smaller repair bill yourself may cost less than making a claim.
- Know your deductible. Compare it with the repair estimate and the amount your insurer would actually pay.
- Check your claims-free status and whether accident forgiveness applies before making a decision.
- Follow all reporting requirements. An accident may still need to be reported to the police, a collision reporting centre or your insurer even if you pay for your own repairs.