Can My Car Insurance Rates Go Up for No Reason?

3 minutes can save you hundreds. Enter your postal code below and join thousands of Canadians saving on car insurance.

Secure. No Spam. No Fees.

Why Use MyChoice

MyChoice.ca is an independent platform that helps Canadians find their best insurance options and make informed financial decisions. Our service is free to use. We may earn a commission from some providers when you buy a policy, but it never affects the price you pay or how products are reviewed. To help ensure accuracy, our content is researched and reviewed by licensed insurance professionals before publication.

First published on August 15, 2024

3 minute read

MyChoice follows a strict content review process designed to ensure reliable and unbiased information.

Car insurance premiums in Canada increased 6% between December 2022 and December 2023, indicating that the country continues to face industry challenges. But if you’re a good driver with a clean record, can your insurance rates go up for no reason? We provide answers.

Rising Car Insurance Rates at a Glance

  • Car insurance rates can rise even if you have a good driving record. External factors like where you live, inflation, and climate change can influence how much you pay for car insurance.
  • Generally, car insurance rates in Canada are on the rise because of rampant vehicle health and a significant increase in claims.

Can Car Insurance Go Up Without an Accident?

Accidents are the leading cause of rising auto insurance premiums, with 2022 marking the second-highest fatality count (1,931 deaths) since 2013. So, what if you haven’t had a road accident? Unfortunately, your insurance rates can still rise for other reasons, including the following.

Tickets & Other Violations

While accidents significantly impact insurance premiums, speeding tickets and other violations on your motor vehicle report, such as demerit points, can also increase your rates. Why? A bad record tells insurers that you’re a high-risk driver.

Personal Changes

Where you live heavily influences how much you pay for car insurance, so making a personal change like moving to a new city can raise costs. For example, if you previously lived in a rural area and moved to an urban town with more congested roads, you can expect your premiums to rise.

Other personal changes, such as getting married, can impact your insurance rates. Married couples often pay less for car insurance. 

Climate Change

Yes, climate change can influence your insurance rates! Areas more prone to natural disasters like storms and wildfires often force insurance companies to cover claims for catastrophes and extreme weather events.

Vehicular Theft

In 2022, over 105,000 cars were stolen in Canada, with Interpol listing it as one of the worst countries for cart theft. These hefty losses almost always drive claims and cause insurance rates to soar.

Consider the top most frequently stolen cars before you buy a new one.

Inflation

If inflation can negatively impact other industries, it can definitely affect your car insurance. Insurance rates will also rise if a vehicle becomes more expensive to repair and replace. Factors like the cost of parts replacement and labor shortages can also affect these rates.

Renewal

Similar to renting property, renewing your car insurance policy will typically increase rates. How much change occurs will depend on your rating factors, such as if you’ve recently relocated or added a new driver to your policy. 

reasons your car insurance rates can go up

What You Can Do to Keep Your Car Insurance Rates Lower

While many factors that cause car insurance rates to rise are often out of your control, there are things you can do to keep your premium costs manageable.

Take a Driving Course

Staying accident-free and proving you’re a safe driver can speak volumes about your reliability to an insurance company. Proving that you’ve taken a safe driving course can give your insurance provider peace of mind. Plus, there’s no harm in sharpening your driving skills.

Maintain a Good Credit Score

Drivers with good credit often have lower premiums. While your credit score may be a minor consideration for most insurance companies, having good credit communicates to insurers that you’re a reliable client.

Buy the Right Car

The cost of insuring one car will differ from another. Consider electric vehiclesβ€”while they benefit the environment, they can be hard on your wallet, as replacing and repairing parts costs more.

If you’re in the market for a new vehicle, consider the cheapest cars to insure.

Bundle Your Insurance Policies

Bundling auto and home insurance can save you money, as most insurance companies offer discounts. You can also consider multi-vehicle insurance, simplifying the process of paying premiums and making them easier to manage.

Pay Premiums Up Front

If you have the budget to spare, paying for your entire policy term up front can save between 6% and 14% on your premiums.

Compare Insurance Quotes

If you don’t have a car insurance policy yet, shop around. Don’t jump at the first policy you see – you might not get the best deal. Remember, each insurer has variable rates based on how they evaluate you as a driver. For instance, one insurance company may consider your age and vehicle type more heavily than another. 

Depending on your driver type, consider alternative companies. Suppose you aren’t always on the road and drive less than 11,000 miles annually. You might find a better deal with a low-mileage insurance company. 

Pick the Best Policy

While auto insurance is a requirement for all Canadians, what type of policy you select can determine how high (or low) your rates are. Liability-only insurance policies have the lowest rates but don’t provide ample protection. On the other hand, collision or comprehensive coverage will provide more benefits if you get into an accident but may cost you more in the long run.

Key Advice From MyChoice

  • Understand why your rates have risen – they won’t increase for no reason. Review personal and social factors, economic factors, and environmental factors.
  • Take your time shopping for the right vehicle and the auto insurance company with the best rates. 
  • Practice good habits to keep your insurance rates low, such as prioritizing road safety, keeping your credit score healthy, and ensuring your car is in good condition.

With over a decade in Canada’s insurance sector, Aren is a leading voice in the industry, providing thought leadership on auto insurance, underwriting innovation, and how technology is reshaping insurance.

Congratulations! You made it to the end!

Now, here is the easy part: complete your quote in under 2 minutes

Discover More About

July 23, 2026
What happens if your car is declared a total loss in Ontario? Learn how insurers calculate payouts, when vehicles are written off, and how OPCF 43 protects you.
July 8, 2026
Staged collisions, re-VINing, fake documents and repair fraud cost insurers millions each year. Learn how that affects your premiums in Ontario.
June 20, 2026
Canada’s senior driver population is growing. Learn how aging demographics could influence future auto insurance risk

Even More Ways To Save on Insurance